Download Ebook The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie
When getting the e-book The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie by on-line, you can review them wherever you are. Yeah, also you are in the train, bus, waiting checklist, or various other locations, online book The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie could be your great buddy. Every single time is a good time to read. It will enhance your expertise, enjoyable, entertaining, lesson, and experience without investing even more cash. This is why online publication The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie comes to be most really wanted.
The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie
Download Ebook The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie
The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie. What are you doing when having leisure? Talking or surfing? Why do not you try to review some e-book? Why should be reviewing? Reading is among enjoyable as well as satisfying activity to do in your downtime. By checking out from several resources, you could locate brand-new information and also encounter. The books The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie to review will be countless beginning with scientific books to the fiction publications. It means that you can check out the publications based on the necessity that you really want to take. Naturally, it will be different and also you can review all publication kinds at any time. As right here, we will certainly show you a book should be checked out. This e-book The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie is the selection.
It can be one of your morning readings The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie This is a soft data publication that can be survived downloading and install from on-line book. As recognized, in this advanced era, technology will certainly alleviate you in doing some activities. Even it is merely reading the presence of publication soft data of The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie can be additional function to open up. It is not only to open and also save in the gizmo. This time around in the morning as well as other free time are to read guide The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie
Guide The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie will still give you favorable worth if you do it well. Finishing guide The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie to check out will certainly not become the only goal. The goal is by obtaining the favorable worth from guide until completion of guide. This is why; you need to find out more while reading this The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie This is not only how quickly you read a book and also not only has how many you finished the books; it is about what you have obtained from the books.
Thinking about the book The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie to check out is also needed. You could select guide based on the preferred themes that you such as. It will engage you to love reviewing other publications The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie It can be additionally regarding the requirement that obliges you to check out the book. As this The Trouble With Aid: Why Less Could Mean More For Africa (African Arguments), By Jonathan Glennie, you could locate it as your reading publication, even your preferred reading publication. So, find your favourite publication here as well as get the link to download and install guide soft documents.
Africa is poor. If we send it money it will be less poor. It seems perfectly logical, doesn't it? Millions of people in the rich world, moved by images on television and appalled by the miserable conditions endured by so many in other countries, have joined campaigns to persuade their governments to double aid to Africa and help put an end to such shameful inequality.
It seems simple. But it isn't. In this book, Jonathan Glennie argues that, along with its many benefits, government aid to Africa has often meant more poverty, more hungry people, worse basic services and damage to already precarious democratic institutions. Moreover, calls for more aid are drowning out pressure for action that would really make a difference for Africa’s poor. Rather than doubling aid to Africa, it is time to reduce aid dependency. Through an honest assessment of both the positive and negative consequences of aid, this book will show you why.
- Sales Rank: #1699890 in eBooks
- Published on: 2012-11-15
- Released on: 2012-11-15
- Format: Kindle eBook
Review
'Readable, reasoned yet radical; Glennie urges governments, campaigners and others to look beyond aid and consider other ways to help impoverished nations and citizens stand on their own feet.' Alex Wilks, European Network on Debt and Development 'Jonathan Glennie's excellent and immensely readable new book presents a compelling case for those of us who care about Africa not to demand ever more aid, but rather to seek the more fundamental changes in the global economy which could reduce dependency on aid and contribute to the ultimate eradication of poverty.' David Woodward, former head of New Global Economy Programme 'Jonathan Glennie offers a refreshing and insightful departure from the polarized views that have dominated the aid debate. Clearly and succinctly he challenges both aid optimists and aid sceptics with an in-depth analysis of the 'complex impacts' of aid on the lives of the poor and the institutions and governments of recipient countries. A must read' Samuel Gayi, UNCTAD 'At last a book that speaks frankly to the fundamentals of aid and how it is delivered. Ignore this book at your peril; this is an issue we cannot relegate to the sidelines of development' Charles Mutasa, Africa Forum and Network on Development and Debt (AFRODAD) 'The Trouble with aid certainly hits the spot. A concise and forthright critique and summary of the aid dilemma, its lack of prohibitive jargon and lofty rhetoric afford it wide and deserved appeal' New Agriculturalist
About the Author
Jonathan Glennie is director of policy and research at Save the Children UK, as well as a visiting fellow at the International Development Institute at King's College London.�
�
Most helpful customer reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
A comprehensive critique of the aid system
By John Gibbs
Poverty seems to be a simple problem. Just add money and it goes away. Unfortunately that is not how it works. Aid has actually increased poverty, prevented the economic development of recipient countries and resulted in dependency and destruction of government agencies and accountable government, according to Jonathan Glennie in this book.
The author says that the impacts of aid are usually not measured, and when they are measured the measurements do not include the indirect impacts of aid, and in particular the negative effects of aid on the basic institutions needed for economic stability and effective government in recipient countries, and the macroeconomic effects of large inflows of foreign money. Trade and investment policies are far more important to Africa's long-term economic growth, but it is much easier to get rich countries to agree to send some charity than it is to get them to change their trade policies.
The author suggests that donors and recipients should aim to halve aid by 2020, while taking other measures to fill the financing gap and support poverty reduction. Firstly, he recommends plugging the leaks which cause more money to leave Africa each year in illicit capital flight, investment abroad, debt repayments and bolstering central bank foreign exchange reserves than the total amount of aid received. Next, African governments need to raise revenue through well-designed taxation systems. An appropriate mix of protectionism and trade liberalisation needs to be adopted to foster economic growth. Donor countries should be spending more on development in Africa, but through technology and investment, not aid.
The book is quite short at 143 pages, but filled with interesting facts and stories about problems with the aid system. Some might be tempted to give up on trying to help the poor after seeing all the problems, but that is not the author's intent; instead, he argues that we should be expending greater efforts and resources in helping the poor, not through more aid, but though something that works.
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
Various reviews of "The Trouble with Aid"
By Various reviews
Comments on Jonathan Glennie's 'The Trouble with Aid'
Alex de Waal (Program Director, Social Science Research Council): "This is a really fantastic book and one of the most accessible and well argued books on aid available."
Madelaine Bunting (Guardian journalist): "Dambisa gets lots of coverage... but ['The Trouble with Aid'] is much better...."
Owen Barder (Center for Global Development): "There are lots of rather dull, very worthy books about the aid business, and in my view this is not one of them. This is a short readable book full of anecdotes and examples about the way that aid works and missing out all the lofty rhetoric that you often read... So the ideas that might otherwise be quite boring, such as aid conditionality, are brought to life with examples that illustrate and support the arguments... It doesn't slip into jargon, which is one of its great strengths."
Emma Mawdsley (Cambridge University, for the Journal of International Development): "Glennie has produced an intelligent, judicious and accessible dissection of foreign aid to Africa. It ought to rocket to the top of any reading list on the subject, and in an ideal world it would displace the recent populist publications on foreign aid from the bestseller lists... He is unsparing in his insistence on evidence, and on not conforming to scripts... With a discernment and clarity that seems to elude many in the field, Glennie asks deceptively simple questions, but ones which I suspect will disconcert both aid pessimists and aid optimists. He concludes with a full chapter on prescriptions for change, and in keeping with the rest of the book, these are potentially achievable, radical and realistic at the same time. What they require is willingness to embrace a more holistic, evidence-led and situated understanding of aid effectiveness in reducing poverty... 'The Trouble With Aid' is a tremendously good book. It is written with great clarity, and students will have no problem following the arguments; but at the same time it sets out discerning arguments that academics and policy-makers will find refreshing and challenging."
Richard Dowden (Director, Royal African Society): "Brilliant... incisive, clearly written and with radical conclusions."
Duncan Green (Head of Research, Oxfam GB): "a crisp, well-argued book"
Robert Molteno (Political scientist and publisher): "['The Trouble with Aid's'] lines of argument ought to command attention for many years to come... The arguments, always nuanced rather than simplistic and sweeping, [provide] the bones of a constructive, alternative development and aid policy."
Samuel Gayi (Team Leader on UNCTAD's annual Economic Development in Africa report): "The book presents a challenge to both aid optimists and aid sceptics through an in-depth and perceptive analysis of the multidimensional and "complex impacts" of aid, and associated policy conditions, on the lives of the poor, institutions, and government policies of recipient countries. Jonathan Glennie offers a refreshing and insightful departure from the polarized views that have dominated the aid debate... The message of the book is particularly timely as it exhorts governments to use aid efficiently and effectively for it to make a real difference to the lives of poor people at a time when donors are struggling to meet their own aid targets. The call for enhanced domestic financial resource mobilization ("minimizing outflows and maximizing domestic resources") is critical if recipient governments are to recapture their policy space... The book is well-structured, and written in a clear, fluid, succinct, and engaging language that enthrals the reader to the end. It is a must-read not only for students of Development Studies/Economics, but also for development experts, politicians and policy makers in recipient and donor countries as it brings critical insights to some old perspectives."
David Woodward (former head of New Global Economy Programme at the New Economics Foundation): "Jonathan Glennie's excellent and immensely readable new book presents a compelling case for those of us who care about Africa not to demand ever more aid, but rather to seek the more fundamental changes in the global economy which could reduce dependency on aid and contribute to the ultimate eradication of poverty."
Charles Mutasa (Director of the African Network on Debt and Development, AFRODAD): "At last a book on aid by a colleague from the north that speaks frankly to the fundamentals of aid and how it is delivered. What Jonathan has given us is not just his perspectives but new insights into the constraints on development in the Third World. The book cannot be ignored..."
New Agriculturalist: "'The Trouble with Aid' certainly hits the spot. A concise and forthright critique and summary of the aid dilemma, its lack of prohibitive jargon and lofty rhetoric afford it wide and deserved appeal... Glennie offers some suggestions on how to get the aid revolution started."
Alex Wilkes (Head of the European Network on Debt and Development, EURODAD): "A very informative read for anyone interested in the future of development policy... A well argued account of aid's problems and potentials and the importance of other policy agendas if we are serious about helping Africa. Readable, reasoned yet radical; Glennie urges governments, campaigners and others to look beyond aid and consider other ways to help impoverished nations and citizens stand on their own feet."
Richard Aidoo (Africa Today): "Well-thought-out, ['The Trouble with Aid'] responds to both the optimists and the pessimists in the aid debate... Glennie's arguments have contributed to other scholarly discussions which build on the idea of not just increasing aid, but providing support that will really help Africa's development."
Lucy Corkin (SOAS, for Pambazuka News): "What makes this book unique is the attempt to collect and synthesize the entire range of arguments for and against aid, in a way that lays bare the complexities of the issue. This is no easy task and Glennie is painstaking in his effort to capture the nuances of arguments... Glennie has done an admirable job in keeping the tone of the book balanced, recognising the importance of conveying a message in a way that, albeit hard to swallow, has a hope of being digested.
D.J. Shaw (Development Policy Review): "[Glennie] suggests not a sudden break but a deliberate change of direction..."
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
A new look at aid
By David
I like this book. It crams a great deal of good sense into a short space. In particular the author understands how institutional failure and weakening of the indigenous executive and legislative process within African Governments can be actually caused by the existence of a large foreign aid sector and budgetary dependence on it. In other words Aid undermines the very Governance objectives it purports to address. The book is different - maybe paradigm-changing - in really focusing on this problem rather than on the extensively discussed and more minor issues like technical aid effectiveness. It is this perspective which lends credibility to the call for reducing aid. But oddly, ater all this insight, he ends up with a solutions chapter which seems to leave behind his central argument. His solutions are all about money per se, not institutions. For example recapturing reserves, preventing capital flight, reducing theft; lowering rich country subsidies, more DFI. These are all important but have been discussed ad mauseam elsewhere. Where is the strengthening of the institutional framework and how will it be developed indigenously?? By what societal mechanisms is such money likely be deployed to support genuine indigenous institutional development? These for me are the real questions for African independence and development.
The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie PDF
The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie EPub
The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie Doc
The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie iBooks
The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie rtf
The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie Mobipocket
The Trouble with Aid: Why Less Could Mean More for Africa (African Arguments), by Jonathan Glennie Kindle
No comments:
Post a Comment